pneuman generator

| | Comments (1)

All-Star Superman #1, then. I've been waiting for this one eagerly ever since it was announced--Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely are the only team that's pulled off this many mainstream comics projects successfully since Claremont/Byrne, and part of what I love about them is that (unlike Claremont/Byrne) they don't just do their thing on every comic they work on. They think really hard about look-and-feel. The Invisibles wasn't like Flex Mentallo, which wasn't like Earth 2, which wasn't like New X-Men, and none of that was like We3. And their Superman is, once again, a new tack for them.

The All-Star concept (famous characters, big-name creators, The Way You Like It) seemed a little dubious to me--especially since DC hasn't been trying to do mainstream outreach with it the way Marvel handled the Ultimate titles--and All-Star Batman & Justice have both been the kinds of pretentiously serious claptrap that makes me roll my eyes so hard I can see my ears. Morrison's concept for Superman, though, is audacious enough that it works: The Best Comic about The Best Hero. The point isn't dramatic impact or conceptual complexity the way it is in some of his other comics, it's page-for-page wheeeeee! value. And this isn't a gently winking homage to the Mort Weisinger-era stuff the way, say, Alan Moore's "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?" was: it's Morrison (and Quitely) figuring out what made those comics work, and how to do the same thing ramped up for 2005.

Specific things I love: the compressed narrative playing out in what looks like contemporary decompressed style (which really just means space for Quitely's drawings to breathe--it reads very quickly, but there's actually a whole lot of stuff happening); the four-panel, eight-word origin recap that opens the first issue (and doesn't it contrast nicely with All-Star Batman's tooth-gritting multi-issue expansion of Robin's origin?); Jimmy Olsen's helmet, jet-pack and "super-watch"; the way we jump smack into Luthor's "reformation" and fall by way of Perry White's blatantly expository dialogue, and Luthor's motivation; Dr. Quintum's rainbow jacket and I'm-going-to-be-a-villain-later-on foreshadowing; "The DNA P.R.O.J.E.C.T."; "the infinitesimal yoctosphere"; Clark disguising his three-steps-ahead reflexes as clumsiness; and that wonderful cliffhanger at the end.

Baffling thing: given Morrison's insistence that Superman "always finds a way to solve every single problem without anyone being hurt," what's he doing throwing the "self-actualizing" suicide bomber into the sun in Morrison's very first story?


gabe said:

I thought it was the "self-actualizing" bit that got Supes off the hook: letting a being die in the way that it's genetically programmed to die doesn't conflict with his code against killing. (Otherwise he should be working on a cure for cancer.) Throwing the human bomb guy into the sun didn't kill him -- it just gave him a place to explode without harming anyone else.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Douglas published on November 17, 2005 1:02 AM.

be be be be be was the previous entry in this blog.

three trout jumping (reflected) is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Powered by Movable Type 4.0